Second homes and investment property

How rental homes, vacation property and land are classified, valued and taxed in a Virginia or North Carolina divorce.

The two states value property on different dates. Virginia values it as of the evidentiary hearing unless the court sets another date for good cause (Va. Code § 20-107.3); North Carolina values marital property as of the date of separation and divisible property as of the date of distribution (N.C. Gen. Stat. § 50-21). Growth in a separate property's value stays separate in Virginia unless marital property or a spouse's significant personal effort caused substantial appreciation. In North Carolina, the increase in value of separate property is separate, while passive changes in marital property after separation are divisible property (§ 50-20). For taxes, a home that is not the main residence does not qualify for the federal home sale exclusion (IRS Publication 523).

Part of The home and the law

Who it is for

Straightforward caseOwners of one extra property dividing it by agreement.
Complex caseOwners of several properties or rentals whose income and value are disputed.

Key terms

Personal effort
In Virginia, labor, skill or management applied directly to separate property. An increase in its value is marital only to the extent such effort or marital property contributed to it.
Divisible property
In North Carolina, property divided along with marital property, including changes in the value of marital property after separation that are not the result of a spouse's postseparation actions, and passive income from it.
Passive income
A term North Carolina's equitable distribution statute uses without defining it: passive income from marital property received after the date of separation, including interest and dividends, is divisible property.
Capital gain
The gain from selling a capital asset for more than its adjusted basis. IRS Topic 409 says almost everything owned and used for personal or investment purposes is a capital asset, such as a home, household furnishings, and stocks or bonds held as investments.

Official sources

3 pages

  1. A rental house or vacation home in a Virginia divorce: classifying, valuing and dividing investment property

    A rental or vacation home in a Virginia divorce: separate, marital or part of each, rent and personal effort, the mortgage, the hearing-date value and the federal tax rules for a transfer or sale.

  2. A vacation or second home in a North Carolina divorce: value, carrying costs and the tax on a sale

    How a vacation or second home is valued and divided in North Carolina, and the tax on a transfer or sale.

    · in effect until December 31, 2028

  3. A rental house in a North Carolina divorce: value, rents and taxes

    A rental in a North Carolina divorce: marital and divisible property, the two valuation dates, rent received since the separation, co-owners' rents and the federal tax rules.