A HELOC is not a refinance: taking an ex off the mortgage
For a recently divorced Suffolk homeowner who kept the house: which loan actually takes a former spouse off the mortgage, a refinance, an assumption or a home equity line. Wendell Ashgrove is invented; every rule, figure and office in his story is real and cited.
The deed changed. The mortgage did not.
"Well," Wendell Ashgrove said to nobody, on the Monday after he signed the final settlement. "The house is mine. The mortgage is ours."
He had kept the house in Suffolk, a three-bedroom the two of them had owned together for nine years. The agreement gave him the house, gave her a buyout payment, and gave him a set number of months to take her off the loan. She had signed a deed. He had assumed, for about a day, that the deed was the end of it.
It was not. The CFPB puts it in one line: "taking your name off a home or vehicle title doesn't take your name off the mortgage or auto loan." A divorce decree or property settlement may assign a debt to one spouse, but a creditor "can still collect from anyone whose name appears as a borrower on the loan or debt," and a person is generally responsible for a debt "unless you were contractually released by the creditor" or the former spouse "refinanced the loan and removed your name" (CFPB, debt after a divorce). That last rule begins "While state laws vary."
So the deed answered who owns the house. The mortgage answered who owes for it. Those were, as Wendell told his spreadsheet, two separate problems, which is one more problem than a house should have.
What a HELOC and a home equity loan are
That Friday a coworker said the word HELOC as if it settled things. Wendell spent the long weekend finding out what it was.
The CFPB's own definition: "A home equity line of credit (HELOC) is an 'open-end' line of credit that allows you to borrow repeatedly against your home equity," where equity is "the value of your home minus the amount you owe on your mortgage." The owner can generally borrow up to the limit during the "draw period"; after it ends, "you stop being able to borrow from your HELOC and enter the 'repayment period.'" HELOCs "usually have a variable interest rate," and "if you fall behind or can't repay the loan on schedule, you could lose your home" (CFPB, HELOC).
A home equity loan "allows you to borrow money using the equity in your home as collateral." The money comes "as a lump sum," usually at "a fixed interest rate," and "if you cannot pay back the HEL, the lender could foreclose on your home" (CFPB, home equity loan).
The sentence that ended the weekend's theory came from the CFPB's comparison of the two: "For both home equity loans and HELOCs, if you already have a mortgage these new loans would be considered second mortgages that you'd need to pay in addition to your first mortgage" (CFPB, home equity loan or HELOC).
In addition to. The first mortgage, with both names on it, stays where it is. None of the CFPB's pages describe either product as removing a borrower from the existing loan; its page on debt after divorce names the ways a name comes off, a release by the creditor or a refinance.
What a buyout refinance does under Fannie Mae's rules
A refinance replaces the loan rather than adding to it. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide lists among the acceptable uses of a limited cash-out refinance "paying off the existing first mortgage," "financing the payment of closing costs, points, and prepaid items," and "buying out a co-owner pursuant to an agreement" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.3-02).
Under the heading "Refinances to Buy Out An Owner's Interest," the same section says: "A transaction that requires one owner to buy out the interest of another owner (for example, as a result of a divorce settlement or dissolution of a domestic partnership) is considered a limited cash-out refinance if the secured property was jointly owned for at least 12 months preceding the disbursement date of the new mortgage loan." Its conditions, as the guide states them:
- Documentation of at least 12 months of joint ownership, except in the case of a recent inheritance of the property.
- "All parties must sign a written agreement that states the terms of the property transfer and the proposed disposition of the proceeds from the refinance transaction."
- "The party buying out the other party's interest must be able to qualify for the mortgage pursuant to Fannie Mae's underwriting guidelines."
- "Borrowers who acquire sole ownership of the property may not receive any of the proceeds from the refinancing."
Separately from the buyout payment, any cash back to the borrower or another party is capped at "the greater of 1% of the new refinance loan amount or $2,000" (B2-1.3-02). Nine years of joint ownership cleared the 12 months. The question left was the third bullet.
A cash-out refinance is a separate category. It normally requires a borrower on title for six months, but there is no waiting period if the borrower "was legally awarded the property (divorce, separation, or dissolution of a domestic partnership)," and the rule that a first mortgage being paid off "must be at least 12 months old" does not apply "when buying out a co-owner pursuant to a legal agreement" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.3-03). Which category a refinance falls into, and whether Fannie Mae's rules apply at all, is the lender's determination.
Qualifying on one income: debt-to-income limits
The fear Wendell did not say out loud was that his income looked too thin to qualify alone.
Fannie Mae's guide says: "For manually underwritten loans, Fannie Mae's maximum total DTI ratio is 36% of the borrower's stable monthly income," and the maximum can be exceeded up to 45% "if the borrower meets the credit score and reserve requirements reflected in the Eligibility Matrix." "For loan casefiles underwritten through DU, the maximum allowable DTI ratio is 50%." The ratio compares the borrower's total monthly obligations, including the qualifying payment on the new loan, with income used to qualify (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02).
His spreadsheet, as an example only: on stable monthly income of $6,000, 36 percent is $2,160 in total monthly obligations, 45 percent is $2,700, and 50 percent is $3,000. "That is the arithmetic," he said. "It is not an approval." The lender decides what income counts, what the payment would be and which limit applies.
Assumption and release: what federal law does and does not do
On Sunday he read about the other way: keeping the existing loan and having his former spouse released from it.
Federal law protects the transfer itself. For a loan secured by a home with fewer than five dwelling units, "a lender may not exercise its option pursuant to a due-on-sale clause upon" a list of transfers, including "(7) a transfer resulting from a decree of a dissolution of marriage, legal separation agreement, or from an incidental property settlement agreement, by which the spouse of the borrower becomes an owner of the property" (12 U.S.C. § 1701j-3(d)). (A due-on-sale clause lets the lender declare the loan due when the property is transferred.) The statute keeps the lender from calling the loan over the divorce transfer. It says nothing about releasing the former spouse.
Release has its own rules, written for particular kinds of loans:
| Loan | Rule | What it says |
|---|---|---|
| FHA-insured | 24 CFR 203.510 | Where release is permitted, "the mortgagee shall release a selling mortgagor from any personal liability for payment of the mortgage debt" when the purchaser is found creditworthy and assumes personal liability by agreeing to pay the debt, on a release form HUD approves. A separate automatic release after five years has its own conditions. |
| VA home loan | 38 U.S.C. § 3714(a)(1) | Except as subsection (f) provides, a veteran or other person who disposes of the property and notifies the holder in writing beforehand "shall be relieved of all further liability to the Secretary with respect to the loan" if the holder determines that the loan is current and the purchaser assumes full liability and qualifies from a credit standpoint. |
Both rules speak of a seller and a purchaser, and the VA release covers liability "to the Secretary." How either fits a transfer between former spouses, and whether any other loan allows a release, is the servicer's question. Wendell's loan was neither, so he wrote it down for his.
Suffolk's assessment: how often, how to ask for a review, how to appeal
The last paper in the stack was the city's assessment notice, the only one with just his name on it.
The City of Suffolk's Real Estate Assessor "assesses all real estate at fair market value." "Each parcel of real estate in the City is assessed annually, effective as of the following July 1st," and a notice showing the current and proposed values is mailed to every owner (City of Suffolk, The Assessment Process). Notices go out each spring, and values are "not necessarily changed every year" (City of Suffolk, assessor FAQ). State law requires a general reassessment in cities every two years but does not affect "the power of any city to use the annual or biennial assessment method" (Va. Code § 58.1-3250).
- Review by the assessor. An owner with concerns about the value or the property data contacts the Assessor's office, and "an appointment can be made to meet with the individual appraiser that handles the property." The informal review is not required, and it "ends once the date for formal appeal hearings passes." The office is at 442 W Washington Street, Suffolk, VA 23434, phone 757-514-7475 (City of Suffolk, The Assessment Process; also on the Real Estate Assessor page).
- Board of Equalization. A formal appeal goes to the Board of Equalization, citizens appointed by the Circuit Court, and the Board's decision may be appealed to the Circuit Court (The Assessment Process).
- The deadline. The city pages checked do not state the Board's filing date. State law lets the city set by ordinance the date applications for relief are due, no earlier than 30 days after the end of the period the assessing officer sets to hear objections, and says "all such deadlines shall be clearly stated on the notice of assessment" (Va. Code § 58.1-3378).
- The burden. Before the Board, "there shall be a presumption that the valuation determined by the assessor is correct," and the taxpayer must show "by a preponderance of the evidence" that the property is valued above fair market value or that the assessment is not uniform and not arrived at under generally accepted appraisal practices (Va. Code § 58.1-3379(B)).
Whether a lender uses the city's assessed value for anything, these pages do not say. That went on the list too.
What the rules leave to your own case
The rules, restated: a home equity line or loan adds a second mortgage; it does not replace the first. A deed changes who owns the house, not who owes the mortgage. A refinance or a creditor's release takes a name off, and a Fannie Mae buyout refinance needs 12 months of joint ownership, a signed agreement and a buyer who qualifies under its guidelines. The divorce transfer cannot trigger a due-on-sale clause, but that releases no one. Suffolk reassesses yearly, and its Board of Equalization hears formal appeals.
What they leave open: whether a lender approves a refinance, which category it falls under and what income it counts (the lender); whether an existing loan can be assumed with a release (the servicer); what a settlement's refinance deadline and fallback terms require, and what happens if the refinance is not approved (a licensed attorney); and the Board's filing date for a given year (the notice of assessment, or the Assessor's office). Related guides are collected under disputes over refinancing, signing the settlement, the first year after a divorce and home equity and property taxes.
Related guides on this site: Refinancing into one name: what lenders count while you separate; Still co-owners after a Virginia divorce: rights, costs and partition.