The homestead exclusion and the circuit breaker in North Carolina: two property tax programs side by side
For Johnston County homeowners nearing 65 or living with a disability, and checking whether one income can carry the house: who qualifies for each program, what each removes or postpones, and how to apply.
The two programs side by side
Both are claimed on the Department of Revenue's Form AV-9, Application for Property Tax Relief (2027 form; 2026 form), and the circuit breaker borrows the exclusion's definitions and income limit (§ 105-277.1B(b), (c)).
| Point | Homestead exclusion (§ 105-277.1) | Circuit breaker deferment (§ 105-277.1B) |
|---|---|---|
| Age or disability | 65 or older, or totally and permanently disabled | The same |
| Income, preceding calendar year | Up to the income eligibility limit: $39,900 for the 2027 tax year ($38,800 for 2026) | Up to 150% of it: $59,850 for 2027 ($58,200 for 2026) |
| Time in the home | No minimum in § 105-277.1 | Owned at least five consecutive years and occupied at least five years as a permanent residence |
| Residency and test date | North Carolina resident; conditions met as of January 1 before the tax year | The same |
| Effect | The greater of $25,000 or 50% of the appraised value is excluded from taxation | Tax above 4% of income (up to the limit) or 5% (up to 150%) may be deferred |
| Repayment | No repayment provision | A lien; the preceding three fiscal years' deferred taxes come due, with interest, after a disqualifying event |
| Spouses | Full benefit if one spouse meets the age or disability test | Full benefit if one spouse meets the age or disability test and the ownership and occupancy test |
| Other co-owners | Each applies separately; each is capped at that owner's share of the value | Only if all owners qualify and elect to defer |
| Application | Form AV-9 by June 1; once approved, refiled only after certain changes | Form AV-9 by June 1, every year |
Who qualifies, and on what date
Every condition is tested "as of January 1 preceding the taxable year for which the benefit is claimed" (§ 105-277.1(a); § 105-277.1B(d)). For the 2027 tax year that is January 1, 2027, and the income counted is 2026's, the "previous calendar year" on the 2027 form. A 65th birthday after that January 1 misses the age test for that year.
"Totally and permanently disabled" means a physical or mental impairment that "substantially precludes him or her from obtaining gainful employment and appears reasonably certain to continue without substantial improvement throughout his or her life" (§ 105-277.1(b)(4)). The proof is a certificate from a physician licensed in North Carolina or a governmental agency authorized to determine qualification for disability benefits (§ 105-277.1(c)(2)); the form calls for Form AV-9A, Certification of Disability.
Income is "All moneys received from every source other than gifts or inheritances received from a spouse, lineal ancestor, or lineal descendant" (§ 105-277.1(b)(1a)). The limit moves each year by the percentage of any cost-of-living adjustment made to Social Security Act Title II and XVI benefits for the preceding calendar year, rounded to the nearest $100 (§ 105-277.1(a2)). A permanent residence is "A person's legal residence" and includes "the dwelling, the dwelling site, not to exceed one acre, and related improvements" (§ 105-277.1(b)(3)).
How much each program changes the bill
The exclusion works on value: "The amount of the appraised value of the residence equal to the exclusion amount is excluded from taxation" (§ 105-277.1(a)). Above $50,000 of value, half is the larger figure, so the tax is figured on the other half.
The circuit breaker works on income: a qualifying owner "may defer the portion of the principal amount of tax that is imposed for the current tax year on his or her permanent residence and exceeds" 4 percent of income up to the limit, or 5 percent above it up to 150 percent (§ 105-277.1B(f)). The difference is carried forward as deferred taxes (§ 105-277.1B(h)), with interest "as if they had been payable on the dates on which they would have originally become due" (§ 105-277.1F(b)).
An example, with invented figures. The full tax on a residence appraised above $50,000 would be $3,000 for 2027. The owner meets the age, residence and five-year tests, and 2026 income was $36,000, so both programs are open. The exclusion leaves $1,500 to pay and nothing owed later. The circuit breaker leaves 4 percent of $36,000, or $1,440, to pay and defers $1,560. At $48,000 of income only the circuit breaker is open: 5 percent is $2,400, and $600 is deferred.
On a one-income budget, the circuit breaker ties the amount paid to income and the exclusion ties it to value. By September 1 each year the collector must send a notice stating "the amount of deferred taxes and interest that would be due and payable upon the occurrence of a disqualifying event" (§ 105-277.1B(h)), and deferred taxes "may be paid to the tax collector at any time without affecting the property's eligibility for deferral" (§ 105-277.1F(b)).
When deferred taxes come due: a sale, a death, a move, a divorce
The statute lists three disqualifying events: the owner transfers the residence, dies, or "ceases to use the property as a permanent residence" (§ 105-277.1B(i)). Then "The deferred taxes for the preceding three fiscal years are due and payable" (§ 105-277.1B(h)), and the tax for the fiscal year beginning in that calendar year "is computed as if the property had not been classified for that year" (§ 105-277.1F(b)). A year of ineligibility does not trigger payment: the taxes are carried forward, and if the owner qualifies again and a disqualifying event then occurs, "the years in which the owner did not qualify are disregarded" in counting the three (§ 105-277.1B(j)).
A transfer is not disqualifying if "the owner transfers the residence to a co-owner of the residence or, as part of a divorce proceeding, to his or her spouse" and that person "occupies or continues to occupy the property as his or her permanent residence" (§ 105-277.1B(i)(1)). A death is not disqualifying if the owner's share passes to a co-owner or spouse who occupies or continues to occupy the property as his or her permanent residence (§ 105-277.1B(i)(2)).
For an owner weighing whether to keep the house or sell it, § 105-277.1 has no repayment provision, while a circuit breaker sale outside those exceptions makes up to three years of deferred taxes, with interest, due; the lien "is extinguished when the taxes are paid" (§ 105-277.1F(b)). A mortgagee or trustee "that elects to pay any tax deferred" does not acquire a right to foreclose by doing so, and, "Except for requirements dictated by federal law or regulation," a loan term prohibiting deferral "is void" (§ 105-277.1B(l)).
Spouses, separation and co-owners
Husband and wife. A residence "owned and occupied by husband and wife" gets the full exclusion when only one spouse meets the age or disability requirement (§ 105-277.1(d)), and the full circuit breaker when only one meets that and the ownership and occupancy requirements (§ 105-277.1B(e)). "For married applicants residing with their spouses, the income of both spouses must be included, whether or not the property is in both names" (§ 105-277.1(b)(1a)); the form asks, "If married, does your spouse live with you in the residence?"
Other co-owners. Section 105-277.1(e) "applies to co-owners who are not husband and wife," including former spouses still on the title after a divorce. Each applies separately, and each who qualifies may receive the full exclusion, capped at that owner's share of the value, with one exclusion for all together (the cap differs if a co-owner has the disabled veteran exclusion). For the circuit breaker, "no property tax homestead circuit breaker is allowed unless all of the owners qualify and elect to defer taxes" (§ 105-277.1B(e)).
Applying in Johnston County
The 2027 form says, "Submit this application to the county tax assessor where this property is located." By statute an application "should be filed during the regular listing period, but may be filed and must be accepted at any time up to and through June 1 preceding the tax year" (§ 105-277.1(c); § 105-277.1B(n)). Unless extended, the listing period "begins on the first business day of January and ends on January 31," and "The entire period for listing, including any extension of time granted, is considered the regular listing period" (§ 105-307(a), (b)). Spring closes the window: an application for the 2027 tax year must be accepted through June 1, 2027.
The form asks for "the total amount for both spouses" of the previous year's income, with "a copy of the first two pages and Schedule 1 of your federal income tax return" or, without a return, "documentation of the income." Once the exclusion is approved, no new application is needed "unless new or additional property is acquired or improvements are added or removed, necessitating a change in the valuation of the property, or there is a change in the use of the property or the qualifications or eligibility of the taxpayer necessitating a review of the benefit" (§ 105-282.1(a)(2)). The single-application list in (a)(2)c. names § 105-277.1 and not the circuit breaker, both in the version for taxable years beginning before July 1, 2027 and in the one for later years (S.L. 2026-12, s. 3, which adds § 105-277.03), and the form says in capital letters that a new application for it must be filed every year.
For an exemption or exclusion, the assessor "must review the application and either approve or deny" it, and a denial may be appealed "to the board of equalization and review or the board of county commissioners, as appropriate, and from the county board to the Property Tax Commission" (§ 105-282.1(b)). Apart from the June 1 acceptance rule in the program statutes, an application for exemption or exclusion "filed after the close of the listing period may be approved" upon a showing of good cause, and then applies only to taxes levied in the calendar year it is filed (§ 105-282.1(a1)).
In Johnston County the Johnston County Tax Administration Office handles these programs. Its Exemptions, Exclusions and Deferments page (last updated July 31, 2026) gives the limits "For Tax Year 2026" as $38,800 and $58,200 of total income for applicant and spouse, and points to Form AV-9. It and the office's main page list the physical address, 207 E. Johnston Street, Smithfield, NC 27577, 919-989-5130, printed without a label, and taxoffice@johnstonnc.gov. Neither page lists office hours.
What decides between them
No source here ranks the two programs. What sorts them for one owner:
- Income: up to the limit, both are open; above it, up to 150 percent, only the circuit breaker.
- Years in the home: under five, only the exclusion.
- Size: which lowers the bill more depends on value, rates and income.
- Plans for the house: a sale, death or move brings up to three years of deferred taxes due, unless an exception applies; an exclusion leaves nothing deferred.
- Title and paperwork: non-spouse co-owners can each claim a share of the exclusion, but all must qualify for the circuit breaker; one application against one every year.
For someone approaching retirement, age is tested on January 1 and income is the preceding calendar year's, so a change from a retirement or benefits decision, such as wages ending or a pension starting, is measured in the application for the tax year after the year it happens.
What the rules leave to your own case
The sources read here do not say how the spouse rules apply while one spouse has moved out, whether a given payment (support, a rollover, a property settlement) counts as income, how the five-year test applies to a spouse who receives the house in a divorce, or whether the late-application rule reaches a circuit breaker application. The Johnston County Tax Administration Office decides the application and answers those questions; a county board hears an appeal of a denial. Dividing the house, and who pays its taxes during a case, are for a licensed attorney and the court; escrow of deferred taxes is for the lender; and the income tax on a retirement withdrawal is for a tax professional.
Related guides on this site: Appealing a property tax value in North Carolina: the county board of equalization and review; Real estate tax relief for older and disabled homeowners in Virginia: how local programs work.