Military disability pay and retired pay in a Virginia divorce: what the Supreme Court decided in Howell v. Howell
For a Norfolk couple separating as the service member nears retirement: what federal law counts as divisible retired pay, what the Supreme Court decided about pay waived for VA disability compensation, and how Virginia law applies it.
What the federal statute counts as disposable retired pay
Under the Uniformed Services Former Spouses' Protection Act (USFSPA), 10 U.S.C. § 1408, "Subject to the limitations of this section, a court may treat disposable retired pay payable to a member for pay periods beginning after June 25, 1981, either as property solely of the member or as property of the member and his spouse in accordance with the law of the jurisdiction of such court" (§ 1408(c)(1)). U.S. Code text here is current through Public Law 119-142 (November 10, 2026).
"Disposable retired pay" is "the total monthly retired pay to which a member is entitled less amounts which" fall into four groups (§ 1408(a)(4)(A)(i)–(iv)):
- amounts owed to the United States "for previous overpayments of retired pay and for recoupments required by law resulting from entitlement to retired pay";
- court-martial forfeitures, and deductions "as a result of a waiver of retired pay required by law in order to receive compensation under title 5 or title 38";
- for a member retired for disability under chapter 61 of title 10, the amount "computed using the percentage of the member's disability on the date when the member was retired (or the date on which the member's name was placed on the temporary disability retired list)"; and
- deductions for an annuity elected under chapter 73 of title 10 for a spouse or former spouse receiving part of the retired pay under a court order.
Where the former spouse and member "were divorced on or after February 3, 1991," the February 2026 version of the DoD Financial Management Regulation (FMR), Volume 7B, Chapter 29 lists the same deduction: "Amounts waived in order to receive compensation under Titles 5 or 38 of the U.S.C." (¶ 7.1.3.3).
For a division of property in a decree "that becomes final prior to the date of a member's retirement" (and after December 23, 2016, under the statutory notes), the starting figure uses "the member's retired pay base and years of service on the date of the decree," plus later cost-of-living adjustments; for a member who becomes entitled to retired pay under chapter 1223 of title 10, it uses "creditable service points" instead of years of service (§ 1408(a)(4)(B)). That rule applies "For purposes of subparagraph (A)," the definition that lists the deductions. The total payable under all court orders treating the pay as property under subsection (c) "may not exceed 50 percent of such disposable retired pay" (§ 1408(e)(1)).
Why retired pay is waived, and when it is not
"Except as provided in section 1414 of title 10," a retiree eligible for Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) compensation "shall be entitled to receive such pension or compensation upon the filing" of "a waiver of so much of such person's retired or retirement pay as is equal in amount to such pension or compensation" (38 U.S.C. § 5305). Howell gives the usual reason: "since retirement pay is taxable while disability benefits are not, the veteran often elects to waive retirement pay in order to receive disability benefits." VA's regulation adds that "VA will treat as a waiver an application for VA compensation filed by a veteran who is entitled to military retired pay" (38 CFR 3.750(c)(3); eCFR text current as of November 17, 2026).
Two federal programs bear on the waiver:
| Program | Who it covers | Effect under the USFSPA |
|---|---|---|
| Concurrent Retirement and Disability Pay (CRDP), 10 U.S.C. § 1414 | A retiree with a service-connected disability or combination of disabilities "rated as not less than 50 percent disabling," paid both "without regard to sections 5304 and 5305 of title 38" (§ 1414(a)); chapter 61 retirees have special rules (§ 1414(b)) | The FMR says this retired pay "is disposable retired pay and divisible under 10 U.S.C. § 1408(a)(4)" (¶ 7.2.1.1) |
| Combat-Related Special Compensation (CRSC), 10 U.S.C. § 1413a | A combat-related disabled retiree "who elects benefits," paid up to "the amount of the reduction in retired pay" (§ 1413a(a), (b)(2)) | "Payments under this section are not retired pay" (§ 1413a(g)) |
A retiree eligible for both "may receive special compensation in accordance with that section or retired pay in accordance with this section, but not both," and may switch in an annual "open season" (§ 1414(d)).
What Mansell and Howell decided
In Mansell v. Mansell, 490 U.S. 581 (decided May 30, 1989), the question was whether state courts "may treat as property divisible upon divorce military retirement pay waived by the retiree in order to receive veterans' disability benefits." The Court answered: "We hold that they may not." There, as Howell later noted, the waiver "took place before the divorce proceeding."
Howell v. Howell, 581 U.S. 214 took up a waiver made long after the divorce. A 1991 Arizona decree gave the spouse 50 percent of the member's retirement pay; about 13 years after the 1992 retirement, the veteran's election waived "about $250 per month of the roughly $1,500" the two shared, and the Arizona courts ordered him to restore her share. The Supreme Court reversed: "Our cases and the statute make clear that the answer to the indemnification question is 'no.'" "Regardless of their form, such reimbursement and indemnification orders displace the federal rule and stand as an obstacle to the accomplishment and execution of the purposes and objectives of Congress. All such orders are thus pre-empted." And "State courts cannot 'vest' that which (under governing federal law) they lack the authority to give."
The Court also said what remained possible: "a family court, when it first determines the value of a family's assets, remains free to take account of the contingency that some military retirement pay might be waived, or, as the petitioner himself recognizes, take account of reductions in value when it calculates or recalculates the need for spousal support" (citing Rose v. Rose and 10 U.S.C. § 1408(e)(6)). The next sentence begins "We need not and do not decide these matters," and says the state courts' decisions "rested entirely upon the need to restore" the former spouse's lost portion.
How Virginia's property statute applies the federal rule
In Virginia, the part of any pension or retirement plan "acquired by either spouse during the marriage, and before the last separation of the parties," when at least one spouse then or later intends the separation to be permanent, "is presumed to be marital property in the absence of satisfactory evidence that it is separate property" (Va. Code § 20-107.3(A)(2), text as amended effective July 1, 2026). The court "may direct payment of a percentage of the marital share," "shall only direct that payment be made as such benefits are payable," and "No such payment shall exceed 50 percent of the marital share of the cash benefits actually received by the party against whom such award is made." The same paragraph adds: "Any determination of military retirement benefits shall be in accordance with the federal Uniformed Services Former Spouses' Protection Act (10 U.S.C. 1408 et seq.)" (§ 20-107.3(G)(1)).
The court decides a division "after consideration of" eleven factors, among them "The ages and physical and mental condition of the parties" (§ 20-107.3(E)(4)); the statute does not mention disability waivers. The court's continuing authority includes modifying an order "in a case filed on or after July 1, 1982," that divides retirement benefits under federal law, "only for the purpose of establishing or maintaining the order as a qualified domestic relations order or to revise or conform its terms so as to effectuate the expressed intent of the order" (§ 20-107.3(K)(4)).
Agreements are treated differently. "Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent the affirmation, ratification and incorporation in a decree of an agreement between the parties pursuant to §§ 20-109 and 20-109.1" (§ 20-107.3(I)). In Yourko v. Yourko (Record No. 220039, March 30, 2023), a Military Pension Division Order entered with the final divorce decree recorded the parties' negotiated agreement and provided that the member would indemnify the former spouse "by giving to her directly the amount by which her share or amount is reduced." The Supreme Court of Virginia reversed the Court of Appeals, adopted that court's earlier holding in Owen that, with regard to the division of military retirement benefits, "federal law does not prevent a husband and wife from entering into an agreement to provide a set level of payments, the amount of which is determined by considering disability benefits as well as retirement benefits," and wrote: "For similar reasons, Howell is not implicated when a court seeks to enforce an otherwise valid indemnification provision. Rather, by the plain language of the opinion, Howell is only implicated when a court seeks to circumvent the USFSPA by ordering indemnification."
Spousal support, the other opening Howell named
In setting spousal support, "the court shall consider" factors that begin with "The obligations, needs and financial resources of the parties, including but not limited to income from all pension, profit sharing or retirement plans, of whatever nature" (Va. Code § 20-107.1(E)(1)). Later, "Upon petition of either party the court may increase, decrease, or terminate the amount or duration of any spousal support and maintenance that may thereafter accrue" (§ 20-109(A)), within limits the rest of that section sets, including for support fixed by a filed stipulation or contract (§ 20-109(C)).
Federal law also separates support from property. Federal pay "based upon remuneration for employment" is open to legal process "to enforce the legal obligation of the individual to provide child support or alimony," including VA compensation paid to a retiree "if the former member has waived a portion of the retired or retainer pay in order to receive such compensation" (42 U.S.C. § 659(a), (h)(1)(A)(ii)(V)); other "periodic benefits under title 38" are not included (§ 659(h)(1)(B)(iii)). "Alimony" there excludes a payment "in compliance with any community property settlement, equitable distribution of property, or other division of property between spouses or former spouses" (§ 659(i)(3)(B)(ii)).
The Norfolk court, and why the dates matter before retirement
"The circuit court shall have jurisdiction of suits for annulling or affirming marriage and for divorces" (Va. Code § 20-96). For a case filed in Norfolk, that is the Norfolk Circuit Court, 4th Judicial Circuit, 150 St. Paul's Boulevard, 7th Floor, Norfolk, VA 23510-2773. Its page lists the phone (757) 389-8942 and Clerk's Office hours of 8:45AM - 4:45PM, and says: "Uncontested divorces are heard Monday through Thursday from 9:00 a.m. to 11:50 a.m. and set through the Clerk." Other guides for the city are on the Norfolk page.
For spouses separating now with retirement ahead, the dates fall in order: the marital share is what was earned "during the marriage and before the last separation of the parties," if at least one of them intended the separation to be permanent (§ 20-107.3(G)(1)); a property division in a decree final before retirement uses the decree-date figures described above (§ 1408(a)(4)(B)); and a § 5305 waiver is filed by a person "who is receiving pay" under a law providing retired pay. Howell's remark speaks of the moment a court "first determines the value of a family's assets." More guides for this stage are under approaching retirement.
Checking three statements a reader may meet elsewhere
| Statement (a forum, a relative, an AI tool) | What the sources say |
|---|---|
| "A Virginia judge can order the veteran to make up whatever the disability waiver took from the former spouse's share." | Not as an order the court imposes: such orders, "Regardless of their form," "displace the federal rule," and "All such orders are thus pre-empted" (Howell). An agreed provision is different: "Howell is not implicated when a court seeks to enforce an otherwise valid indemnification provision" (Yourko). |
| "The disability waiver exclusion is 10 U.S.C. § 1408(a)(4)(B)." | That was the numbering before a 2016 amendment; the provision "now appears at § 1408(a)(4)(A)(ii)" (Howell). Today's § 1408(a)(4)(B) sets the figure for a division of property in a decree final "prior to the date of a member's retirement." |
| "Any VA rating shrinks the former spouse's share, and VA pay can never be reached." | With a service-connected disability or combination of disabilities "rated as not less than 50 percent disabling," a retiree is paid both "without regard to sections 5304 and 5305 of title 38" (§ 1414(a)), subject to chapter 61 rules, and the FMR calls that pay "disposable retired pay and divisible" (¶ 7.2.1.1). For child support or alimony, VA compensation paid after a waiver can be reached (42 U.S.C. § 659(h)(1)(A)(ii)(V)). |
Other checked claims are under checking an AI tool's answer.
What the sources leave to your own case
Howell left open how far a family court may account for a possible waiver, and Virginia's statute names no method. Whether a valuation, a support award or an indemnification clause holds up in one case is for the court to decide and a licensed attorney to advise on; Yourko speaks only to an "otherwise valid" provision. Whether a waiver, CRDP or CRSC applies to a member, and in what amount, is answered by VA and the military's own offices: a waiver statement goes "to VA or to the Federal agency that pays the veteran's military retired pay" (38 CFR 3.750(c)(3)), and a retiree may "apply to the Secretary of a military department" to be considered for CRSC (10 U.S.C. § 1413a(d)).
The Virginia State Bar's Virginia Lawyer Referral Service, at (800) 552-7977 (labeled "statewide & nationwide toll-free"), Monday-Friday, 9am–5pm, collects a "$35.00 non-refundable referral fee" for "an up to one half-hour (30 minute) consultation." The Armed Forces Legal Assistance locator lets "Individuals eligible for military legal assistance" find "the nearest legal assistance office," though its information "is limited to certain CONUS bases." Related guides are under military divorce finances and final decisions on property and debt.
Related guides on this site: Dividing military retired pay in Virginia when retirement is near; The Survivor Benefit Plan after a military divorce: former spouse coverage and the one-year deadline.