Dividing a family business in a Virginia divorce: valuation, classification and payment over time
How Va. Code § 20-107.3 classifies and values a company, what the court can order, and what it leaves to the valuation method. Beatrix Quillmane is invented; every rule, legal figure and office in her story is real and cited.
Two appraisals, one company, two numbers
Beatrix Quillmane is 58. She runs a marine-supply company in Newport News with fourteen employees, and she started it four years before her wedding, out of one rented bay. She and her spouse separated last spring after 24 years of marriage. The divorce is filed in the Newport News Circuit Court, and the hearing on the property is months away. (All figures for her company are invented for this story.)
She paid for an outside valuation and read every page of it. It put the company at $1.1 million. Her spouse's appraiser put it at $1.6 million.
"Same company," she told her attorney. "Same books. Half a million dollars apart. Which number does the law use?"
Neither, as a matter of statute. Va. Code § 20-107.3, in the version in force on November 19, 2026 (last amended in 2026, chapter 470), says the court "shall determine the legal title as between the parties, and the ownership and value of all property, real or personal, tangible or intangible, of the parties," and does so "upon request of either party" (§ 20-107.3(A)). It says when value is measured. It does not say how. The word "method" appears in the section only once, in the phrase "the method of payment" in subsection E, and the section does not mention goodwill at all.
"So the method is evidence," Beatrix said. "Not law."
Separate, marital, or part of each
Before value comes classification. The company existed before the marriage, so it starts as separate property: § 20-107.3(A)(1) defines separate property to include "all property, real and personal, acquired by either party before the marriage."
The growth is the harder question. Under the same subdivision, "the increase in value of separate property during the marriage is separate property, unless marital property or the personal efforts of either party have contributed to such increases and then only to the extent of the increases in value attributable to such contributions." The efforts "must be significant and result in substantial appreciation of the separate property" before any increase counts as marital.
The statute defines the term that matters most for an owner-operator. "Personal effort" means "labor, effort, inventiveness, physical or intellectual skill, creativity, or managerial, promotional or marketing activity applied directly to the separate property of either party" (§ 20-107.3(A)(3)(a)).
"That's my whole job description," Beatrix said.
The same subdivision sets the order of proof. The nonowning spouse "shall bear the burden of proving that (i) contributions of marital property or personal effort were made and (ii) the separate property increased in value." Once that burden is met, "the owning spouse shall bear the burden of proving that the increase in value or some portion thereof was not caused by contributions of marital property or personal effort." Income from separate property follows a similar rule: it is marital "only to the extent it is attributable to the personal efforts of either party."
A business started during the marriage begins on the other side of the line. Property acquired by either spouse during the marriage and before the last separation, "if at such time or thereafter at least one of the parties intends that the separation be permanent, is presumed to be marital property in the absence of satisfactory evidence that it is separate property" (§ 20-107.3(A)(2)).
The valuation date, and a year when the income changed
Since the separation, Beatrix's largest customer has cut its orders, and the company's revenue fell. Her appraiser valued the company on current numbers. Her spouse's appraiser leaned on the year before.
The statute's default date is the later one: the court values property "as of the date of the evidentiary hearing on the evaluation issue." Its one exception is narrow and has conditions: "Upon motion of either party made no less than 21 days before the evidentiary hearing the court may, for good cause shown, in order to attain the ends of justice, order that a different valuation date be used" (§ 20-107.3(A)). A different date takes a motion, a deadline, good cause and the court's decision; the court may grant it, and is not required to.
"So the date is the hearing, unless a judge moves it," Beatrix said. "The argument is what we were worth on it."
A change in income can matter a second time. Subsection F says the court determines a monetary award "without regard to maintenance and support" and, at that time or after, on either party's motion, considers whether a support order should be entered, modified or vacated. In a spousal support decision, the factors in Va. Code § 20-107.1(E) include "the obligations, needs and financial resources of the parties," "the provisions made with regard to the marital property under § 20-107.3," and "the earning capacity" of each party (more under a new job or income change).
The loan both spouses signed
In the ninth year of the marriage, the company borrowed for a second warehouse, and Beatrix's spouse signed the loan papers with her.
The statute classifies debt as well as property. "Marital debt" includes "all debt incurred in the joint names of the parties before the date of the last separation of the parties, if at such time or thereafter at least one of the parties intends that the separation be permanent," and debt incurred in either party's name during the marriage and before that separation. It carries an exception: if a party shows "by a preponderance of the evidence that the debt, or a portion thereof, was incurred, or the proceeds secured by incurring the debt were used, in whole or in part, for a nonmarital purpose," the court may designate all or part of it as separate (§ 20-107.3(A)(5)).
The debt is measured on a different date from the property: the court determines its amount "as of the date of the last separation of the parties," with the same condition on intent, and "the extent to which such debt has increased or decreased from the date of separation until the date of the evidentiary hearing" (§ 20-107.3(A)). Beatrix has paid it down from cash flow every month since.
The court "shall also have the authority to apportion and order the payment of the debts of the parties, or either of them, that are incurred prior to the dissolution of the marriage," and may divide or transfer "jointly owed marital debt," based on the factors in subsection E; factor 7 is "the debts and liabilities of each spouse, the basis for such debts and liabilities, and the property which may serve as security for such debts and liabilities" (§ 20-107.3(C), (E)(7)). The section speaks to the spouses and says nothing about what a lender must do, so whether the bank would release one signer is a question for the bank. More is under dividing shared debt.
What the court can order, and how payment over time works
Beatrix's fear was a forced sale. The company's membership interest is in her name alone. Subsection C says the court "shall have no authority to order the division or transfer of separate property or marital property, or separate or marital debt, which is not jointly owned or owed," except as subsection G provides for retirement benefits, and except that the court may return one party's separate property held by the other. Marital property "is presumed to be jointly owned unless there is a deed, title or other clear indicia that it is not jointly owned" (§ 20-107.3(A)(2)). The spouse's interest in marital property "shall not attach to the legal title of such property" and is used only "as a consideration in determining a monetary award" (§ 20-107.3(B)).
"So the court can't hand over half my company," she said. "It can hand me a bill."
The bill is the monetary award:
| Subsection | What the text says |
|---|---|
| D | A monetary award is "payable either in a lump sum or over a period of time in fixed amounts, to either party." |
| D | The paying party "may satisfy the award, in whole or in part, by conveyance of property, subject to the approval of the court." |
| D | The award is a judgment under § 8.01-426, "shall not be docketed by the clerk unless the decree so directs," and "may be enforceable in the same manner as any other money judgment." |
| D | The interest rules of § 8.01-382 "shall apply unless the court orders otherwise." |
| E | The amount of the award and "the method of payment" are set after the 11 factors, including "the liquid or nonliquid character of all marital property" (factor 8). |
| K(1), K(2) | The court may "order a date certain for ... payment of any monetary award" and punish "any willful failure" to comply as contempt. |
"What does it cost to pay over time?" Beatrix asked. Under Va. Code § 8.01-382, a judgment or decree that does not provide for interest bears interest "at the judgment rate of interest as provided for in § 6.2-302 from its date of entry." Va. Code § 6.2-302(A) sets that rate at "an annual rate of six percent," except that a money judgment in an action arising from a contract carries the contract rate or six percent, whichever is higher; under subsection C, the rate in effect when the judgment is entered is not affected by later changes to the rate the section states. Section 20-107.3(D) lets the court order otherwise.
"Six percent, unless the judge says different," she said. "That goes in the cash-flow sheet."
The statute does not mention security for installments, and its percentage rules cover only retirement benefits and injury recoveries (subsections G and H); subsection E lists factors, among them "the duration of the marriage" and "the ages and physical and mental condition of the parties." The spouses may also settle: under subsection I, nothing in the section prevents the court from incorporating their agreement into the decree under §§ 20-109 and 20-109.1 (see final decisions on property and debt).
Basis, taxes and the years before retirement
If Beatrix satisfied part of an award by conveying property, federal tax law would apply to the transfer. Under 26 U.S.C. § 1041 (2024 edition of the U.S. Code; the section's last listed amendment is from 1988), "no gain or loss shall be recognized" on a transfer of property to a spouse, or to a former spouse "if the transfer is incident to the divorce." The property is treated as acquired by gift, and "the basis of the transferee in the property shall be the adjusted basis of the transferor" (§ 1041(b)). A transfer is incident to the divorce if it "occurs within 1 year after the date on which the marriage ceases" or "is related to the cessation of the marriage" (§ 1041(c)). The section has exceptions, including for a spouse who is a nonresident alien (§ 1041(d)).
"The basis travels with it," Beatrix said. Virginia's statute makes "the tax consequences to each party" a factor in the award (§ 20-107.3(E)(9)).
At 58, she also thinks about the years after work. Under § 20-107.1(F), "Any order granting or reserving any request for spousal support shall state whether the retirement of either party was contemplated by the court and specifically considered by the court in making its award," and, if so, the facts the court considered (see approaching retirement).
Where a Newport News case is heard
"The circuit court shall have jurisdiction of suits ... for divorces" (Va. Code § 20-96). The preferred venue for a divorce is "the county or city in which the parties last cohabited," or, at the plaintiff's option, where the defendant resides if a Virginia resident, with a further option when an order of publication may issue (Va. Code § 8.01-261(19)). Beatrix and her spouse last lived together in Newport News.
The Newport News Circuit Court and Clerk's Office is at 2500 Washington Avenue, Courthouse Building, Newport News, VA 23607-4307, in the 7th Judicial Circuit of Virginia. The court's page lists the phone as (757) 926-8561, Clerk's Office hours of 8:00AM - 4:30PM, Land Records hours of 8:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m., and "Court convenes 10:00 a.m." Orders that transfer real property between the spouses are recorded in the land records of the circuit court clerk where the property is located (§ 20-107.3(C)). Other guides for the city are on the Newport News page.
What the rules leave to your own case
Va. Code § 20-107.3 classifies property as separate, marital or part of each, values it as of the evidentiary hearing unless a timely motion and good cause lead the court to another date, measures debt from the separation, bars, with narrow exceptions, court-ordered transfers of property not jointly owned, and allows a monetary award in a lump sum or fixed amounts over time. It leaves open:
- Which valuation method fits a particular company, how goodwill is treated, and how competing appraisals are weighed: questions for the evidence, a licensed attorney and, in the end, the court.
- Whether growth during the marriage came from significant personal effort and caused substantial appreciation, and in what share: a factual question the burdens of proof in subdivision A(3)(a) frame and the court decides.
- Whether a different valuation date has good cause: the court, on a motion made no less than 21 days before the hearing.
- How a company loan both spouses signed fits subdivision A(5): the court; whether a lender will release a co-signer: the lender, under its own loan documents.
- Whether an operating agreement or shareholder agreement limits a transfer, and how a buyout schedule is secured: a licensed attorney.
- How § 1041 and basis apply to a specific transfer or payment: a tax professional.
The general rules are on the dividing property and debt page.
Related guides on this site: Dissipation of marital property in a Virginia divorce: what the statute lets a court consider; How Virginia divides property and debt when spouses separate.